An approval only means something if the right person gives it, before payment, with the evidence in front of them.
A sound expense approval workflow sends every claim to the claimant's line manager, never to the claimant, and escalates senior staff claims to someone more senior or independent. Finance checks policy compliance before payment. Write down delegation rules for absences, set approval limits, keep the approval date on record and test monthly for self-approval and approvals outside the reporting line.
The line manager and finance do different jobs. The manager knows whether the trip happened. Finance knows whether the claim meets the policy. Skipping either one leaves a gap.
Many teams add a second approver above a set amount, or for categories such as travel booked outside the travel policy, gifts and entertaining. Set limits that suit your business and write them into a simple matrix, as you would for supplier payments. See the payment approval limits matrix for a layout you can reuse.
Claims stall when approvers are away. Decide in advance:
Export paid claims with A claim ID, B claimant, C approver, D approval date, E payment date and F amount. Keep an HR list of employees and their line managers in a table named HR with columns Employee and Manager.
Self-approval
=IF(B2=C2,"Self-approved","")
Approver is not the line manager
=IF(XLOOKUP(B2,HR[Employee],HR[Manager],"Not found")<>C2,"Check approver","")
Approvals by a more senior manager or a recorded delegate will also flag; clear them against the delegation log.
Paid before approval
=IF(OR(D2="",E2<D2),"Paid before approval","")
Reciprocal approvals
=IF(COUNTIFS($B:$B,C2,$C:$C,B2)>0,"Reciprocal","")
Run these each month and record the outcome. Add the expense claim audit checklist tests for duplicates and receipts.
A short checklist on the approval screen helps approvers who approve claims in bulk on a phone.
The workflow is the same in the UK and the US. UK teams often say "expense claims" and "line manager"; US teams say "expense reports" and "supervisor". Tax treatment of expenses differs, so finance checks should follow current HMRC or IRS guidance.
Matches every company card transaction to its expense claim, and flags spend nobody claimed, claims made twice, missing receipts and splits under the approval limit. Runs in your browser on your own computer: nothing is uploaded.
Score a payment request against the warning signs of fraud. Free to use online.
The Expense Claims & Corporate Card Audit System tests for exact duplicates, duplicates across employees and split purchases, flags approval problems, missing receipts, late submissions and blocked merchants, and matches card claims to the card statement, with an Expense Audit Playbook (PDF). Excel, no macros, one-time price.
Someone independent, commonly the finance director, with the chair or audit committee reviewing them periodically. The key point is that nobody approves their own claim.
Finance should check policy compliance before payment, which is different from management approval. Large teams often check every claim against rules and sample the rest in depth.
Use a recorded delegation to their own manager, with start and end dates, and an automatic escalation if a claim waits too long.
Last updated 11 November 2026. General guidance for finance teams; check it against your own policies, systems and local rules.