A reconciliation is only a control if someone independent actually challenges it.
When reviewing a reconciliation, first confirm the balance agrees to the trial balance at the right date. Then check that every reconciling item is supported by evidence, has an owner and a clearing date, and isn't old. Challenge judgement areas such as provisions and accruals, look for unexplained plugs, and sign and date the review only when every question has an answer.
Preparing a reconciliation finds differences. Reviewing it makes sure they were dealt with properly. Without a genuine review, reconciliations drift into lists of old items carried forward month after month. Reviews should be done by someone independent of the preparer who has enough knowledge of the account to challenge it. See the balance sheet reconciliation process.
A quick test in Excel: with the ledger balance in B2, the supporting balance in B3 and the sum of reconciling items in B4:
=ROUND(B2-(B3+B4),2)
should return zero.
Sample a few items and trace them to the evidence yourself. Don't rely on the description.
Ask for every reconciling item to carry the date it arose. With that date in column A and the period end in a named cell ReportDate, =ReportDate-A2 gives its age. Agree a limit, and escalate anything over it. Old items are the clearest sign that a reconciliation is being prepared but not acted on.
For accruals, provisions and prepayments, the question is not only "does it agree?" but "is the amount right?". Check the basis of calculation, whether it is consistent with the prior period, and whether anything has changed that should change it. See accruals and prepayments.
Compare the balance to last month and the same month last year. A large movement with no business reason is worth a question even when the reconciliation balances. See balance sheet flux analysis.
Not every account needs the same depth of review. Rate accounts as high, medium or low risk based on size, complexity, judgement and history of errors. Review high-risk accounts in full every month, and lower-risk accounts in less depth or less often, as your policy allows. Keep the risk ratings under review. See which accounts to reconcile monthly.
The review steps are the same in the UK and US. Businesses subject to formal internal control requirements, such as US companies reporting under Sarbanes-Oxley, usually need documented evidence of each review. Check what your auditors and any regulator expect.
Reviews every balance sheet reconciliation with an on-device AI and 20 review tests, flags vague and wrong-account reconciling items, and builds a risk-ranked review queue. Runs in your browser on your own computer: nothing is uploaded.
12 questions on how strong your close controls are. Free to use online.
The Balance Sheet Reconciliation Library covers the balance sheet with nine working papers: a known error blocks sign-off, every supported balance needs an evidence reference and every aged item needs an owner and a next action. Excel, no macros, one-time price.
Someone independent of the preparer and of the people who post to the account, with enough knowledge to challenge the reconciling items, usually a senior accountant or financial controller.
Ask for a plan and date to clear each one, escalate items over the age limit, and push for a correcting journal or write-off where the item can't be resolved.
Yes, briefly. A zero balance can hide large offsetting entries, especially in clearing and suspense accounts.
Last updated 04 November 2026. General guidance for finance teams; check it against your own policies, systems and local rules.