Most finance teams use both. The question is which reconciliations belong where, and what controls each one needs.
Accounting software is usually best for high-volume bank matching against its own feeds, because rules and matching run on the ledger directly. Excel is usually better where data comes from several sources, where items need investigation notes, or where the reconciliation is a balance sheet working paper. Whichever you use, keep a fixed format, a reviewer sign-off and evidence for every reconciling item.
| Question | Accounting software | Excel |
|---|---|---|
| Bank matching against the ledger's own bank account | Strong: feeds and rules | Works, needs an export each period |
| Supplier statement against the payables ledger | Limited in many systems | Strong: statement and ledger side by side |
| Balance sheet account breakdowns | Usually not built for it | Strong: one working paper per account |
| Notes and owners on open items | Varies by system | Strong, if the template has the columns |
| Audit trail of changes | Strong, built in | Weak unless you add version control and sign-off |
| Risk of formula or copy errors | Low | Real; needs checks and locked formulas |
| Review and sign-off evidence | Varies by system | Needs a sign-off block in the template |
The spreadsheet controls guide covers these in more detail.
Some teams add a dedicated reconciliation tool when volumes or the number of accounts make Excel slow, but the ledger's own matching is not enough. Before buying, list the reconciliations you do, how long each takes and where the errors come from. That list tells you whether the problem is the tool or the process. See bank reconciliation software pricing for how pricing models differ.
The comparison applies equally in the UK and the US. UK teams often say "bank rec" and "supplier statement reconciliation"; US teams say "bank rec" and "vendor statement reconciliation". Audit expectations for evidence and sign-off are similar under both regimes.
AI software that matches your bank statement to your ledger on your own computer and builds the reconciliation statement. $1,997 once-off; see it on the built-in example first.
The Bank Reconciliation Template reconciles up to five bank accounts across eight transaction categories, with an allocation check that confirms every transaction is coded before the reconciliation counts as clean. Excel, no macros, one-time price.
Yes, with controls: a standard template, locked formulas, a balance check, preparer and reviewer sign-off and saved evidence. The risk comes from uncontrolled copies and edits.
Not necessarily. You still need to agree the ledger balance to the bank statement balance at the period end and explain any reconciling items.
Typically supplier statements, intercompany balances, accruals, prepayments, suspense and other balance sheet accounts that need a breakdown rather than a transaction match.
Last updated 11 November 2026. General guidance for finance teams; check it against your own policies, systems and local rules.